Somewhere in Norway

This render doesn't convince me. Something is missing but I don't know what. The foreground at right with the water is the part I like best. The shape of the far mountain looks fine, I think the material choice is not very fortunate. The bright spots look too small to me. These mountains are quite a bit away from the camera and I would expect to have small details more blurred. If the red on the tops comes from a setting or rising sun, it should be much brighter or the parts in the shadow darker.

Certainly good. It seems perhaps a bit incomplete compared to your other works. Everything so far is great. I am beginning to wonder about the red light. It is seeming perhaps too dark to look like light and is looking somewhat like paint.

Material choices look very good on the stones and along the right bank. Water and sky colours along with the clouds, also good. Not quite so enthusiastic about the red splodge in the sky or the lumpy mountains in the background. The mossy effect along the waters edge is excellent, I like that a lot.